We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies in accordance with our Cookie Policy.
  • ::COVID-19 COVERAGE::
  • INDUSTRY PRESS ROOM
  • SUBMISSIONS
  • MEDIA FILE
  • Create Account
  • Sign In
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Free Newsletters
  • MAGAZINE
    • Current Issue
    • Archives
    • Digital Edition
    • Subscribe
    • Newsletters
  • STRATEGY
  • GLOBAL
  • LOGISTICS
  • MANUFACTURING
  • PROCUREMENT
  • VIDEO
    • News & Exclusives
    • Viewer Contributed
    • Upload your video
  • PODCAST ETC
    • Podcast
    • White Papers
    • Webcasts
    • Events
    • Blogs
      • Reflections
      • SCQ Forum
    • Mobile Apps
  • MAGAZINE
    • Current Issue
    • Archives
    • Digital Edition
    • Subscribe
    • Newsletters
  • STRATEGY
  • GLOBAL
  • LOGISTICS
  • MANUFACTURING
  • PROCUREMENT
  • VIDEO
    • News & Exclusives
    • Viewer Contributed
    • Upload your video
  • PODCAST ETC
    • Podcast
    • White Papers
    • Webcasts
    • Events
    • Blogs
      • Reflections
      • SCQ Forum
    • Mobile Apps
Home » Letters to the editor
Chain Reactions

Letters to the editor

December 16, 2011
Supply Chain Quarterly Staff
No Comments

Product fraud: not just in food supply chains
Your story "Consumer product fraud—how to stop it now" (Q2/2011) was a good, thought-provoking article.

Adulteration is not limited to just the food industry; it also affects chemicals and pharmaceuticals. I know a chemical company in Dubai that earned millions of dollars by selling fake chemicals. Once when I was discussing this with a few of their managers, they told me that [this practice] was not limited to their own company. They said there are pharmaceutical companies that manufacture fake generic drugs to earn millions of dollars.

I know that quite a lot of companies indulge in these kinds of nefarious activities to make millions of dollars in profits. They do not care for human health or for doing business ethically.

Radhakrishnan Pillay
Dubai, United Arab Emirates


Store SKU forecasts should guide manufacturers
I enjoyed the article "Are you a candidate for produceto- demand?" (Quarter 3/2011) and agree with James Cooke's comments on produce-to-demand being a better model than the traditional bulk "make-to-stock" model for some manufacturers. However, I would argue that forecasting by SKU (stock-keeping unit) at the store level, and having that information flow back through the supply chain (i.e., from the store to the distribution center to the manufacturer) would produce better results for both the manufacturer and the retailer, in contrast to the manufacturer creating its own forecast.

There is a book called Flowcasting the Retail Supply Chain, by André Martin, Mike Doherty, and Jeff Harrop, which goes into detail about this new method of forecasting. Some of your other readers may find this as interesting as I did.

Rob Dold
Account Executive, Fortna Inc.
Nashville, Tennessee, USA


Why it may be hard to get "a commanding view"
The article "A commanding view" (Quarter 3/2011) presents the reader with a number of concepts that make a great degree of logical sense. The science presented is not new but the adoption rate is slow. There could be several reasons for this, and I would think that many in the CSCMP community would benefit from understanding what contributes to the low adoption rate.

I can see four barriers to adoption:

  1. Cost of implementation. It maybe the case that the necessary systems to reasonably enable a "commanding view" strategy are expensive to implement, and maybe the ongoing maintenance is expensive also.
  2. Speed of implementation. Product lifecycles are getting shorter, with the bulk of sales occurring shortly after product launch. If the time taken to connect new supply partners and configure the system is lengthy, then this may limit the usefulness of adopting this strategy.
  3. Complexity. It may be the case that there are insufficient numbers of people who are trained to implement and run these systems.
  4. Reluctant partners. To enable this level of business intelligence, suppliers, carriers, and customers must be willing to share the necessary business intelligence data. I can see circumstances where suppliers lack sophistication and big customers simply say no to sharing point-of-sale data.

I would like to see an article that presents a real case, with before and after implementation performance numbers, and that talks about cost and speed of implementation together with the availability of information and people who are able to support this new environment.

Alan J. Bishop
Principal, Scoord
Franklin, Tennessee, USA

  • Related Articles

    Executive Insight: Letters to the Editor

    Letters to the Editor

    Letters to the Editor

Recent Articles by Supply Chain Quarterly Staff

BrightDrop delivers 150 electric parcel vans to FedEx network

Survey: 90% of procurement leaders will tweak operating models to cope with economic outlook

J.B. Hunt trials self-driving trucks in Texas pilot

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Most Popular Articles

  • How to resolve your inventory dilemma

  • Container prices continue to drop

  • Regionalized supply chains: the key to resilience

  • Warehouse vacancy rates sink to 27-year low

  • Empty shipping containers stack up at U.S. port depots

Featured Video

Cccb7d13 710a 4473 8132 da8b6cc286f1

The Sportsman's Guide Case study: Increasing Accuracy & Productivity

Viewer Contributed
Thanks to the Lucas Warehouse Optimization Suite, The Sportsman's Guide has increased productivity, reduced training time, and experienced a boost in accuracy for both full-time staff and seasonal employees. Want to learn how Lucas can help your DC be more efficient, accurate, and safe while reducing labor costs?...

FEATURED WHITE PAPERS

  • Case Study: Peak Teams helps boost headcount quickly on a short-term project

  • Breaking Bad: Conducting Full Truckload RFPs in the Age of Digital Freight Procurement

  • Omnitracs One – Last Mile Solutions

  • The enterprise shipper's guide to building a smarter truckload RFP

View More

Subscribe to Supply Chain Quarterly

Get Your Subscription
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • E-NEWSLETTERS
  • ADVERTISING
  • CUSTOMER CARE
  • CONTACT
  • ABOUT
  • STAFF
  • PRIVACY POLICY

Copyright ©2022. All Rights ReservedDesign, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing