We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies in accordance with our Cookie Policy.
  • INDUSTRY PRESS ROOM
  • SUBMISSIONS
  • MEDIA FILE
  • Create Account
  • Sign In
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Free Newsletters
  • MAGAZINE
    • Current Issue
    • Archives
    • Digital Edition
    • Subscribe
    • Newsletters
  • STRATEGY
  • GLOBAL
  • LOGISTICS
  • MANUFACTURING
  • PROCUREMENT
  • VIDEO
    • News & Exclusives
    • Viewer Contributed
    • CSCMP EDGE 2022 Startup Alley
    • Upload your video
  • PODCAST ETC
    • Podcast
    • White Papers
    • Webcasts
    • Events
    • Blogs
      • Reflections
      • SCQ Forum
    • Mobile Apps
  • MAGAZINE
    • Current Issue
    • Archives
    • Digital Edition
    • Subscribe
    • Newsletters
  • STRATEGY
  • GLOBAL
  • LOGISTICS
  • MANUFACTURING
  • PROCUREMENT
  • VIDEO
    • News & Exclusives
    • Viewer Contributed
    • CSCMP EDGE 2022 Startup Alley
    • Upload your video
  • PODCAST ETC
    • Podcast
    • White Papers
    • Webcasts
    • Events
    • Blogs
      • Reflections
      • SCQ Forum
    • Mobile Apps
Home » Canadian Pacific gains advantage in fight to merge with U.S. freight railway Kansas City Southern

Canadian Pacific gains advantage in fight to merge with U.S. freight railway Kansas City Southern

U.S. regulatory board finds that rival bid from Canadian National would not be in the public interest.

CP-locomotive-7.jpg
September 1, 2021
Ben Ames
No Comments

Freight carrier Canadian Pacific Railway (CP) last night took the inside track in its battle with rival Canadian National (CN) to acquire the U.S. rail line Kansas City Southern (KCS), thanks to a decision by U.S. regulators that a CN-KCS merger would be anti-competitive.

At stake is a merger deal valued at $31 billion from CP or $33.6 billion from CN, both of which would be designed to create a continuous rail network spanning the North American continent and connecting Canada, the United States, and Mexico. Despite that argument for the deal, federal regulators may have been disinclined to approve such a path, given a Biden Administration executive order issued in July that pushed back against recent trends toward monopolistic mergers and consolidations.

Specifically, the non-partisan U.S. Surface Transportation Board (STB) yesterday denied a joint application by CN and KCS to create a “voting trust,” a legal arrangement that would have granted control of the combined companies’ ownership shares to a third-party trustee. In theory, that arrangement would have ensured that KCS stayed independently managed pending completion of the STB’s review of the proposed transaction. If full approval were granted, the two companies would then terminate the trust and CN would assume full control of KCS.

In fact, the STB had approved such an arrangement in May for the potential merger of CP and KCS. However, the board found yesterday that the same approach would not work for a CN-KCS combination.

“Applicants have adequately explained how the voting trust agreement would insulate them from an unlawful control violation, but the Board finds that the proposed use of a voting trust, in the context of their impending control application, would not be consistent with the public interest,” the STB said in its decision. “Applicants have failed to establish that their use of a voting trust would have public benefits, and the Board finds that using a voting trust, in the context of the impending control application, would give rise to potential public interest harms relating to both competition and divestiture. Accordingly, Applicants’ motion to approve the use of a voting trust will be denied.”

KCS decried the STB’s decision, saying it still wanted to press ahead with CN’s takeover bid instead of CP’s. “We are disappointed in the STB’s decision to reject CN’s proposed voting trust. We are working with CN to evaluate the options available to us,” KCS said in a release.

Predictably, CN also disputed the finding, claiming that its proposed merger would actually enhance competition, expand North American trade and power economic prosperity, provide new and faster routes, increase supply chain efficiency, and deliver other benefits to the public good. "We remain confident that our pro-competitive, end-to-end combination is in the public interest and that it would offer unparalleled opportunities and benefits for customers, employees, the environment and the North American economy. The combined company would create the premier railway for the 21st century and establish seamless single-line service from Canada, through the United States and into Mexico,” CN said in a release.

According to CP, however, the decision clears the way for a combination of rail networks that would benefit parties throughout the freight ecosystem. “The STB decision clearly shows that the CN-KCS merger proposal is illusory and not achievable,” CP President and CEO Keith Creel said in a release. “Knowing this, we believe the August 10 CP offer to combine with KCS, which recognizes the premium value of KCS while providing regulatory certainty, ought to be deemed a superior proposal. Today, we have notified the KCS Board of Directors that our August 10 offer still stands to bring this once-in-a lifetime partnership together.”

Looking ahead at potential next steps, the transportation industry analyst firm Baird Equity Research said that CP is now “well positioned” to acquire KCS, although the STB’s decision also meant that future merger deals among other class-one railways are “highly unlikely.”

In a note to investors, Baird Senior Research Analyst Garrett Holland said, “Voting trust rejection is the manifestation of regulatory risk and complicates the path to securing deal approval. Following this voting trust denial, we think KSU shareholders will increasingly favor the CP offer, which while lower, represents more realistic value in a combination that is still strategically compelling.”

Rail
KEYWORDS Canadian National Railway Canadian Pacific Railway Kansas City Southern Surface Transportation Board
    • Related Articles

      U.S. regulators approve merger of Canadian Pacific and Kansas City Southern

      Canadian Pacific and Kansas City Southern agree on terms of $31 billion takeover

      Canadian Pacific and Kansas City Southern finalize merger

    Benames
    Ben Ames has spent 20 years as a journalist since starting out as a daily newspaper reporter in Pennsylvania in 1995. From 1999 forward, he has focused on business and technology reporting for a number of trade journals, beginning when he joined Design News and Modern Materials Handling magazines. Ames is author of the trail guide "Hiking Massachusetts" and is a graduate of the Columbia School of Journalism.

    Recent Articles by Ben Ames

    West Coast ports close suddenly in repeat of April work stoppage

    Nearshoring trend shifts trade lanes from China to Mexico, FourKites says

    CMA CGM revenue plunged more than 30% as spot freight rates plunged in Q1

    You must login or register in order to post a comment.

    Report Abusive Comment

    Most Popular Articles

    • Report: Sagging freight stats show that trucking sector is returning to its historic mean

    • Survey: parcel delivery drivers are frustrated by using their own smartphones for work

    • Heavy transport across two continents

    • Survey: most Americans unaware that truckers face shortage of parking spaces

    • Supply chain executives not yet seeing expected results from technology investments

    Featured Video

    20221107korber large vs

    Enhancing Customer Experience with Your Supply Chain Strategy

    Viewer Contributed
    With the rise of e-commerce, many businesses have had to transform their warehouses to handle online orders in addition to regularly scheduled inventory shipments. This means warehouses need more information than ever before to ensure they can meet customers' needs. As a result, companies need to select warehouse...

    FEATURED WHITE PAPERS

    • Three layers of forklift safety: Promoting operating best practices

    • The Complete Guide to Automated Packaging

    • Five tips for parcel success in 2023

    • Guide to Pallet Rack Safety

    View More

    Subscribe to Supply Chain Quarterly

    Get Your Subscription
    • SUBSCRIBE
    • E-NEWSLETTERS
    • ADVERTISING
    • CUSTOMER CARE
    • CONTACT
    • ABOUT
    • STAFF
    • PRIVACY POLICY

    Copyright ©2023. All Rights ReservedDesign, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing